President Obama's cap-and-trade plan could deliver several blows to the U.S. economy, according to a Treasury Department memo that one observer described as "damning."
The country could lose 1 percent of its gross domestic product, face accelerated outsourcing of manufacturing jobs, and experience energy rationing if cap and trade became law, according to the memo, which the Competitive Enterprise Institute obtained under the Freedom of Information Act.
“The memo was damning particularly . . . by pointing out what opponents of cap and trade have long said is the point of cap and trade, and has been proven by Europe’s experience,” said Christopher Horner, a senior fellow at the institute. "You will chase off energy intensive industries — meaning manufacturing jobs. The memo singles out steel, cement, chemical . . . glass, plastic, and ceramics — the same ones that have been clobbered in Europe by this.
“This is the largest outsourcing scheme in history, not just in theory, but in practice,” he said.
The memo, prepared after Obama’s Feb. 24 speech to a joint session of Congress, details Treasury's analysis of the economic impact of cap and trade, which ties climate change to business practices.
The United States gained steel jobs from Spain because the manufacturer's costs under the European Union’s cap-and-trade program chased the jobs to Kentucky, Horner said. However, that foreshadows how cap and trade could cost the United States jobs that move abroad, he said.
The report concludes that cap and trade could result in the loss of the U.S. market share in the global economy.
The administration expects cap and trade to double the economic costs of all environmental regulations to the economy, and Horner said the 1 percent reduction in GDP would “institutionalize recession.”
Cap and trade could generate between $100 billion and $200 billion in federal revenue each year and would increase the cost of existing energy tax provisions, according to the memo.
The Treasury official who wrote the memo suggests using either a carbon tax or a cap-and-trade system that would price carbon at either a fixed tax rate or at a variable market price of emission allowances. The price would be set at a level where firms and consumers would experience enough financial pain to compel them to reduce their emissions.
“Cap and trade has one purpose, and that’s axiomatic, and that is to increase the cost of energy,” Horner said. “The president’s proposal — and that’s what the Treasury is talking about — would cause electricity prices to skyrocket [because] the cost of energy is embedded in everything, so you are talking about a very economically damaging proposal.
Several major protests are scheduled for 12 noon on Thursday, in New York City, Washington, and elsewhere, against Iranian President Ahmadinejad’s scheduled speech in the United Nations.
In New York City, a host of organizations will be gathering outside the UN at Dag Hammerskjold Plaza, 42nd St. & 2nd Ave. The rally will call for “freedom from Iran’s nuclear threat to Israel, America and the free world; freedom from the United Nation’s anti-Semitism and hatred of Israel; freedom from the threat of Radical Islam to the free world; and freedom from Obama’s anti-Israel policy of pandering to the Arab world and pressuring Israel to self-destruct.”
Protestors are being asked to bring Israeli and American flags, as well as banners and signs. “As radical Islam is on the march,” Americans for a Safe Israel/AFSI explains, “fueled by Saudi and Iranian money and terror, abetted by the United Abominations, one has to be prepared to answer the child’s question: ‘What did you do to prevent this from happening?
The wide range of sponsoring organizations includes: Stand for Freedom in Iran Coalition; Progressive American Iranian Committee; StandWithUs, Jewish Community Relations Council of New York; UJA-Federation of New York; National Interagency Task Force on Iran; Retail, Wholesale and Department Store Union; New York City Central Labor Council: AFL-CIO; American Federation of Teachers; United Federation of Teachers; NAACP - New York Conference; The Cathedral of St. John the Divine; New York Coalition of 100 Black Women; Puerto Rican Coalition; 100 Hispanic Women;
At the same time, in Washington, D.C., thousands are expected to participate in a similar rally, entitled “Stand for Freedom From Iranian Threats.” The said threats include terrorism, nuclear bombs, and human rights abuses. This rally, too, will be held Thursday at noon, at Farragut Square Park. “Join the thousands of Americans who stand for freedom from the threat of a nuclear Iran, as President Ahmadinejad addresses the UN General Assembly,” call the two sponsors, the Jewish Federation of Greater Washington and the Jewish Community Relations Council.
Other similar demonstrations will be held elsewhere in the United States against Ahmadinejad and his regime's human rights abuses and nuclear aspirations. Standwithus.com and the Israel Project provide this list: Los Angeles: Wednesday, September 23, 6-10 PM at the Federal Building on Wilshire and Veteran Detroit: Thursday, September 24, 5:30 PM, at Holocaust Memorial Center Zekelman Family Campus in Farmington Hills St. Louis: Thursday, September 24, noon, at Jewish Federation, 12 Millstone Campus Dr